Rub the steak with the butter or oil, then rub the salt and pepper all over its surfaces
Place the steaks into your smoker or grill once it has heated completely. Cook the steaks for 1 to 3 hours, testing every 20 minutes until the desired internal temperature is reached
To finish the steaks, you’ll need to choose a searing method. A cast iron skillet on the stove or a gas grill will do the job quickly, with just two or three minutes needed per side to add some color. If your pellet smoker has a high setting, it can also put a finish on the steaks after about five minutes at the top temperature