How to slow-roast prime rib
Our guide to a slow-roasted prime rib for the holiday table.
Cart
Your cart is empty

The best ribeye temperature for most people is medium rare. That means 130 to 135 degrees F in the center after the steak rests. To get there, pull the ribeye off the heat at about 125 degrees F. It keeps cooking for a few minutes while it sits.
Ribeye is a little different from other steaks because of all that marbling. The fat needs some heat to melt, so a ribeye shines from medium rare to medium. The chart below gives you the pull temp and the final temp for every doneness. After that, you will learn where to put the thermometer, how long to rest the steak, and the mistakes that cost people a great ribeye.
Use the "pull at" column while you cook. That is when the steak comes off the grill, out of the pan, or out of the oven. The "final temp" column is where it lands after a short rest.
| Doneness | Pull at | Final temp after rest | What the center looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rare | 115 degrees F (46 C) | 120 to 125 degrees F (49 to 52 C) | Deep red and cool to warm |
| Medium rare | 125 degrees F (52 C) | 130 to 135 degrees F (54 to 57 C) | Warm red center, pink edges |
| Medium | 135 degrees F (57 C) | 140 to 145 degrees F (60 to 63 C) | Warm pink, no red |
| Medium well | 145 degrees F (63 C) | 150 to 155 degrees F (66 to 68 C) | A thin line of light pink |
| Well done | 155 degrees F (68 C) | 160 degrees F and up (71 C and up) | Brown all the way through |
These numbers match our ultimate guide to steak temperatures. They work for boneless ribeyes, bone-in ribeyes, cowboy cuts and tomahawks. A thicker steak just takes longer to get there.
Here is what each level means for a ribeye, and who it is best for.
Rare ribeye temp (pull at 115 degrees F). The center stays deep red and soft. The trouble is the fat. At rare, most of the marbling has not had time to melt, so the steak can feel chewy and a little waxy. Rare works better for lean cuts like filet mignon.
Medium rare ribeye temp (pull at 125 degrees F). This is the sweet spot for most ribeye fans. The center is warm and red, the fat starts to soften, and the meat stays very juicy. If you are cooking for a crowd and do not know what they like, this is the safe bet.
Ribeye medium temp (pull at 135 degrees F). The center turns warm pink with no red. Ribeye handles medium better than almost any other steak. The extra heat melts more of the marbling, so the steak stays rich and tender. Lots of ribeye lovers swear by it.
Medium well ribeye temp (pull at 145 degrees F). Only a thin band of light pink is left. The steak starts to lose juice here, but the marbling still gives you some cushion. A ribeye at medium well is far more forgiving than a lean steak at the same temp.
Well done (pull at 155 degrees F). The steak is brown all the way through. If you want it this way, use lower heat for the last part of the cook so the crust does not burn before the center catches up.
Want to see what each level looks like on the plate? Our guide to steak doneness walks through the colors and textures one by one.

The ribeye comes from the rib section, the same part of the steer that gives you prime rib. It has more marbling than most steaks. Marbling is the thin white streaks of fat inside the meat.
So while filet mignon is best on the rare side, a ribeye is happiest from medium rare to medium. You can read more about the cut in our complete ribeye cooking guide.
A ribeye is not even all the way through. It has fat pockets, a cap, and sometimes a bone. Where you put the probe matters as much as the number you read.
Check each steak on its own. Two ribeyes on the same grill can finish a minute or two apart, especially if one is thicker.
A steak does not stop cooking the second it leaves the heat. The hot outside keeps pushing heat into the center. This is called carryover cooking, and it is why the chart has two columns.
How much the temp climbs depends on how thick the steak is and how hot you cooked it. Use this table as a guide. Always trust your thermometer over the table.
| Ribeye thickness | Typical rise while resting | Rest time |
|---|---|---|
| About 1 inch | About 3 to 5 degrees F | 5 minutes |
| 1 1/2 inches | About 5 to 7 degrees F | 5 to 8 minutes |
| 2 inches and up (cowboy or tomahawk) | About 5 to 10 degrees F | 8 to 10 minutes |
Steaks seared over very high heat climb more. Steaks cooked low and slow, like a reverse sear, climb less.
Set the steak on a board or warm plate and leave it alone. Do not wrap it tight in foil, or the steam will soften the crust. If you want, lay a piece of foil loosely over the top. Resting also lets the juices settle, so more of them stay in the steak when you slice it.
The pull temps in the chart work no matter how you cook. What changes is how fast the steak gets there.
Grill. Sear over high direct heat, then move the steak to the cooler side if the crust is done before the center. The fat drips and can cause flare ups, so stay close. Get the full steps in our guide on how to grill ribeye.

Pan sear. A hot cast iron pan builds a deep crust fast. Thin ribeyes can finish right on the stove. A pan of rendered fat gets hot, so turn the heat down a little after the first sear. See our steps for how to cook ribeye in a pan.
Oven. For a thick ribeye, sear it in a hot pan, then finish it in a hot oven, around 425 degrees F. The temp climbs fast in a hot oven, so check early and often. Our guide on how to cook ribeye steak in the oven covers the full method.
Reverse sear. Cook the ribeye low first, then sear it hot at the end. This gives the most even color from edge to edge. Pull it from the low heat about 10 to 15 degrees F below your pull temp, then sear it until it gets there. Try our reverse sear ribeye guide.
Sous vide. Set the water bath to the final temp you want, not the pull temp. The steak cannot go past the bath temp, so there is very little carryover. Pat it dry and sear it hard and fast at the end.
The USDA says to cook whole cuts of beef, like steaks and roasts, to at least 145 degrees F and let them rest for 3 minutes. That is the official safe minimum.
Many steak lovers still choose medium rare for whole steaks like ribeye. It is your call. If you are cooking for kids, older adults, someone who is pregnant, or anyone with a weak immune system, cook to 145 degrees F to be safe. Ground beef is a different story. Always cook it to 160 degrees F.
A thermometer gets the inside right. The steak you start with decides how good it can be. Our USDA Prime Ribeye is aged for six weeks, and Prime is the top USDA grade for marbling, so it has even more fat to melt into every bite. For a great everyday steak, the Premium Angus Ribeye is also aged six weeks and ready for the grill.
For a perfect ribeye, pull it at 125 degrees F and let it rest for 5 to 10 minutes. It will finish at 130 to 135 degrees F, a warm red medium rare. If you like a little more fat melted in, pull it at 135 degrees F for medium. Check the center of the eye from the side, and let the thermometer make the call.
Our guide to a slow-roasted prime rib for the holiday table.
Our guide to baking a ham for Christmas dinner.

Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.