Captain Bill’s attracts a number of diners during the summer months for its seafood-centric menu and lakeview dining. While the views are pleasant enough, the food and service have been called some of the worst in Madison by a distressing number of diners. Complaints range from overcooked fish to undercooked pasta to mac & cheese that looks and tastes like it came from a box. Diners also regularly note service gaps of 20, 30, or even 40 minutes. While Captain Bill’s has its defenders, you’re likely better off dining elsewhere in the Madison area.